Friday, February 20, 2009
The Housing Fix
http://money.cnn.com/2009/02/20/news/economy/foreclosure_underwater_jobless/index.htm?postversion=2009022013
Like probably many people who bought their first home in the mid-2000s boom, I'm paying attention to the government's attempts to improve the housing market and the credit crunch. Our family's not at risk for default, and our 30-year-fixed mortgage isn't going to hit us with a sudden extra bill, but (in addition to general economic damage) the decline in housing prices affects our net worth and we're prohibited from refinancing (or selling) because our stake in our home has dropped well below 20%.
Obama's plan makes a tremendous amount of sense to me. It unfortunately doesn't help people who can't afford "any reasonable monthly payment," but a one-time help (dare I say bailout?) for people who are going to default anyway isn't going to help an economic recovery. The plan helps people who aren't in default, but as a stingy fiscal conservative, I also applaud this. I would hate to relatively punish the family who's severely cut back on discretionary spending (of which almost all of us in this country have A LOT of... cable TV anyone?) in order to keep paying their bills. And we should do what we can to make sure that those people can continue to pay their bills, rather than only help them when it's too late and damage is already being inflicted to them and to the economy.
But the referenced Money article talks about Joe Martinez, a story I've heard (about other people) in a number of other places. Joe has a 30-year-fixed mortgage and a steady job, but has lost significant value in his home (hmmm... I can relate to this guy). He's sad that he's lost money in his investment, so he wants the bank to write down the value of his debt. He's willing to stop paying his affordable mortgage in order to qualify for government or bank support in this. And in the extreme case (from other articles), people who can afford their mortgages are walking out of their homes because they'd rather take the credit hit than owe more than their house is worth.
Joe, this is unacceptable. If you like it or not, a home purchased with a loan is an investment. When you invest in something and you lose money (be it houses or stocks or coins), you have to deal with the consequences. The bank had to pay money when you bought the house, and you obligated yourself to pay them back. It is not the bank's fault the house lost value; you made the gamble on the house's value while the bank gambled on your ability to repay a loan that has nothing to do with current value. If you can afford the payments, you need to pay them. Joe's outlook is selfish and infuriating. How are banks to survive when mortgagees who sign a contract don't live up to their side of the bargain? This hurts the financial system and possibly all future mortgages since banks must assume higher risk. If you can't afford your mortgage due to a lifestyle change (loss of job, health problem, etc) I truly feel for you. If you don't pay your mortgage because you choose not to even though you can, you should be severely punished.
In the last couple decades it seems America had brought in a ton of homeowners who don't know what home ownership means. Joe looks at his mortgage as a rental payment that he can stop paying if he's willing to move, rather than a payment on loan where his house is merely collateral. The previous owners of our current house had no notion of home improvement, and when they left were completely confused as to why they couldn't take everything they had purchased for the home, regardless of what our contract said. Home ownership with a mortgage is not rental of a home owned by a bank.
We've probably gotten here because of the huge push for people to own their own homes and live "The American Dream." Maybe this is the problem. As a society we've done this through vastly expanding mortgages so that while many people "own" their homes they see mortgage payments as rent, not as a limited series of payments to pay off a loan. We now see home "ownership" as a right: encourage people to buy their homes at all costs and risks and do everything possible to prevent them from "losing" them. But really... why is home ownership a basic human right? I rented until a few years ago and lived perfectly well. Most of my friends still rent their homes and have wonderful, fulfilling, prosperous lives. In many areas of the country and most of the world renting is the norm. Home ownership is a great thing and offers great potential rewards, but it comes with serious responsibilities. If you don't want the responsibility of maintenance or the risk of loss due to market conditions or natural disasters, you should rent. Supporting home ownership is wonderful, but we must educate and enforce the obligations that come with it.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.